Note: This post is an excerpt from Gould Asset Management’sEconomic and Market Review for the Second Quarter of 2018. The excerpt is posted here for the benefit of our blog subscribers.
US Stocks Move into Positive Territory for 2018 as Market Volatility Subsides
After a volatile start to 2018, US stocks found their footing in the second quarter, rising 3.4% on the period, as measured by the S&P 500 stock index. Most of the gains occurred in May, and US stocks now have risen 2.7% year-to-date. Markets were buoyed by positive earnings momentum, supportive economic data, and a de-escalation of tensions between the US and North Korea. Markets, however, showed they are vulnerable to escalating trade threats, as the Trump administration moved ahead with tariffs on imports from China and several other countries.
Market volatility was mostly subdued in the second quarter after a rather tumultuous start to the year. The VIX implied volatility index was above 20 at the start of April (near its long-term average), however it began trending downward soon thereafter, hitting a tranquil 11.6 in early June, before rising to about 16 at quarter-end. Concerns about the US quitting the Iran nuclear accord and the potential for a US-China trade war had surprisingly little impact on measures of investor fear. (more…)
The question below was posed to Don Gould through Investopedia’s Advisor Insights program. Investopedia.com is a leading provider of online financial educational content and their Advisor Insights program allows investors to post questions to top advisors on a variety of personal finance and investing topics. We will periodically post Don’s responses to some of these questions when we feel they are helpful and of interest to clients and blog subscribers. You can “follow” Don on Investopedia’s website by clicking here.
Question: Where do investors tend to put their money in a bear market?
This question looks simple, but on further inspection, it’s what a trial lawyer might call a “leading question.” As discussed below, it leads to unfounded assumptions about the basic nature of markets.
Let’s start with a few unpleasant facts.
At any point in time, you never know if you are in a bear market, so the question itself is based on the false premise that you do. A bear market—commonly defined as a period in which a given stock index has dropped at least 20% from a peak—can only be identified after the fact. Until the market has dropped 20% from a peak, you are not yet in a bear market. Once it’s dropped 20%, you can say that you were in a bear market, but you still have no idea where the market’s going next or if you are in what will later be viewed as a bear market. Every uptick is potentially the end of a bear market and the beginning of a new bull market.
Consequently, advice about what to do during a bear market is really a fantasy that can only be enjoyed with the benefit of hindsight. Unfortunately, we can’t invest with hindsight. I’m fond of saying, if I knew where the market was going next, I wouldn’t have to provide investment advice for a living.
If stock prices have recently fallen by 20% (or any amount), that information contains absolutely zero predictive value of where they are going next.
Falling stock prices do not, in themselves, tell you anything about how money is moving between, say, stocks and bonds. It is not necessary for even a single share of stock to be bought/sold in order for a stock’s price to fall. The lower price simply means that the equilibrium price (the price at which buyers and sellers are willing to transact) has changed. This happens all the time when a company halts trading in its stock and then makes a major announcement. If the announcement is good (bad) news, the price adjusts upward (downward) without any trades in the stock having taken place.
After a remarkably calm 2017, stock markets turned volatile in the first quarter of 2018. To give just one example, the S&P 500 US large cap stock index had a daily move of more than 1% on 23 occasions in the first quarter (37% of trading days), compared to only 8 times in all of 2017 (3% of trading days).
Whenever the market gyrates, it’s human nature to want to know why. And while the news offered myriad explanations that we’ll touch upon in a moment, our sense is that some of the volatility is a natural outgrowth of a market that for more than a year created the illusion of a risk-free winning bet.
US stocks followed an almost straight-line climb in 2017, but beginning right after New Year’s Day the rise took on a steeper—and unsustainable—trajectory. Through January 26, the S&P 500 leaped 9%—a 200+% compound annualized rate of return!—a pace that no amount of economic and earnings growth could support. As often happens when an asset price goes vertical, a correction ensued. (For a more spectacular example, consider bitcoin). Over the remainder of the quarter, the market gave back all its gains, finishing down about 1% for the quarter as a whole. For more discussion of February’s sudden market correction, see our blog post, “Stock Volatility Comes Out of Hibernation.”
Note: This post is an excerpt from Gould Asset Management’sEconomic and Market Review for the First Quarter of 2018. The excerpt is posted here for the benefit of our blog subscribers.
US Economy Strides into the New Year
Driven by strong consumer spending, fourth quarter GDP expanded at a 2.9% annualized rate, a slight moderation from the third quarter’s brisk 3.2% pace. The US economic expansion will reach 106 months in April, the second-longest on record.
The labor market is strong, with headline unemployment holding steady at 4.1% for the sixth straight month. Wage growth picked up a bit in March, rising 0.3%, as slack in the jobs market is slowly diminishing.
Consumer confidence dipped slightly in March to 127.7 but remains very strong. Respondents remained especially upbeat about labor market conditions.
Home sales struggled to gain traction in the first quarter, limited by rising mortgage rates and home price increases that outpaced wage growth. Greater supply and more take-home pay for buyers could boost sales this spring. (more…)
Stock markets worldwide took a sharp drop today. The S&P 500 fell 4% on the heels of a similar-sized decline last week, erasing 2018’s gains entirely. We are back where we were on New Year’s Eve. It was the worst single-day performance in almost seven years.[1]
After a remarkably long stretch of market appreciation with almost no volatility—the better part of the last two years—the declines of the past few days will no doubt come as a shock to the system for many investors. However, from our perspective the plunge in some ways reflects a return to normalcy.
Stocks have higher long-term expected returns than bonds and cash, but it’s never been a free lunch. Stocks can be volatile; their higher returns are the compensation investors expect for enduring a sometimes bumpy ride. And indeed stocks have rewarded investors handsomely over the long-term. Still, 2017’s nearly uninterrupted climb was abnormal and, as noted in our quarterly letter last month, could easily have lulled some stock investors into a false sense of security.
Financial pundits, of course, must find explanations for the recent nosedive, just as they rationalized boundless optimism only two weeks ago. We don’t envy their job. The proximate cause of the big declines today and Friday was the release of positive employment and wage data late last week. Good economic news paradoxically is sometimes bad news for markets. In this case, the news may mean more and faster short-term rate hikes by the Fed, as well as the potential for higher inflation that pushes up longer term interest rates. Higher bond yields provide more competition for stocks and eventually could also temper economic growth.
The nature of today’s drop—a sharp descent concentrated in the last two hours of trading—suggests a selling frenzy not directly connected to any major new information, but instead driven by some combination of automated computer trading and emotional reaction triggered by the previous declines. Last week’s economic news notwithstanding, we see no fundamental factors that would dictate a big change in the investment landscape. Underlying economic indicators remain strong, making it entirely possible that stock prices had simply moved up too far, too fast. In that case, letting some air out of the balloon now may help avoid a more severe correction down the road.
The decline of the past several days may have further to run; no one can say for sure. On these occasions, we remind clients that their time horizons are measured in years and often decades. The key to reaching long-term goals is discipline—sticking with the long-term game plan, rebalancing portfolios when necessary, and keeping an even keel in an ever-changing world. Our job is to help you do just that. If you find rough financial seas disturbing your peace of mind, please give us a call. We’re here for you.
The Gould Asset Management Team
[1] The Wall Street Journal notes that it was the biggest one-day drop ever in the Dow Jones Industrial Average—true, but arguably a misleading headline since the Dow’s 4.6% drop today pales in percentage terms when compared to its 20+% one-day crash in October 1987.
Note: This post is an excerpt from Gould Asset Management’sEconomic and Market Review for the Fourth Quarter of 2017. The excerpt is posted here for the benefit of our blog subscribers.
US Stocks Surge Higher as Tax Reform Passes, Capping Stellar 2017
US stocks put an exclamation point on an already strong year, as markets rallied around the prospect of cuts to corporate and personal tax rates. The S&P 500 rose 6.6% in the fourth quarter to finish the year up a remarkable 21.8%. The reduction in the corporate tax rate to 21% served as the centerpiece of the tax reform bill, and investors expect this will boost after-tax earnings of US companies going forward. Good economic growth and an uptick in corporate profitability also contributed to the strong quarter.
The financial and technology sectors posted the largest gains in the fourth quarter, rising 8.6% and 8.5% respectively on the period. Technology’s nearly 35% rise in 2017 was a top story, but the market rally was relatively broad-based, with consumer discretionary, materials, industrials, financials, and healthcare all rising over 20% on the year. As a whole, US stocks posted positive returns in every single month in 2017, the first time this has happened since 1958.
Mid and small cap US stocks modestly underperformed large caps on the quarter as well as on the year, rising 4.8% in the fourth quarter, and 17.8% for the year as measured by the Wilshire 4500 stock index. Historically, small and mid cap stocks have proven more volatile than large caps and offered somewhat higher returns to compensate, although that hasn’t been the case over the past five years. Over 10 and 15-year periods, however, smaller companies still maintain a performance edge, suggesting investors would be wise to maintain allocations to both asset classes.
Market volatility remained subdued in the fourth quarter and was a key theme throughout 2017. The VIX volatility index mostly hovered between 9 and 11 throughout the quarter, far below its long term historical average of 20. VIX closed at its lowest level ever (9.14) on November 3rd. This was remarkable considering the quarter saw a rate hike by the Fed, tax reform debated and passed by Congress, and continued tensions with North Korea. (more…)
The crypto craze hit full bore in the fourth quarter, headlined by Bitcoin and several other digital currencies that boasted astounding returns in 2017 (Bitcoin returned a tidy 13,277% last year). The Bitcoin boom has all the hallmarks of a bubble. To wit:
A price chart in which the slope gets steadily steeper, ultimately approaching a vertical line
A situation where buyers are piling in for no other reason than that the price has been rising, coupled with an assumption that there will be other buyers at yet higher prices when it’s time to sell
A price that cannot in any way be connected to value
But what exactly is Bitcoin? In brief, it’s a digital currency that exists independent of the global banking system. Currencies like the dollar require a central bank (e.g., the Fed) to function. In contrast, cryptocurrencies rely on a decentralized and reportedly “incorruptible” ownership registry maintained through an innovative technology known as blockchain, supported by strong encryption to make it safe from theft or alterations. Transactions in Bitcoin are also untraceable, making it a favored currency for both privacy advocates and criminals alike.
The supply of Bitcoin is strictly capped. Bitcoin is “mined” by solving computational tasks that sequentially require ever more computer processing power. It is estimated that cryptocurrency mining now consumes more than one-half of one percent of all electricity worldwide. That’s a remarkable amount of resources to expend for…well, we’re not sure what. (more…)
We enter 2018 on the heels of a strong 2017 for stock markets worldwide. The S&P 500’s 21.8% return is well above the 12.1% average annual return for the index[1]. Foreign markets did better still, with the MSCI EAFE (foreign developed markets) up 25.6% and the MSCI Emerging Markets returning 37.8%, both in roughly the 75th percentile of historical returns.
Animal Spirits on the Rise
Lately the financial press is throwing around the word “euphoria” a lot, and with good reason. In just 11 trading days since New Year’s, the leading US large cap stock index, the S&P 500, is up almost 5%. To put this in perspective, we’ve seen close to one-half of a year’s average return in about 1/25th of a year. Clearly, this rate of ascent is not sustainable.
There are other signs that a bullish mania may be taking hold of investor psyches. Most obvious is last year’s 13,277% run-up in Bitcoin, a virtual currency with no objective yardstick for worth. (For more discussion on the cryptocurrency craze, see here) Along the same lines, we read that margin debt (money borrowed for the purpose of buying stocks) is at record highs, while many investors are abandoning the use of derivatives for hedging stock market downside risk.
The informal term FOMO (Fear of Missing Out) is increasingly invoked in financial market discussions. And why not? When the stock market seems only to go up, it’s easy to feel foolish for owning any conservative assets (for example, bonds) to protect against a risk that seems no longer to exist.
Be assured, the risk is always there. We like to say that the three most dangerous letters in investing are I, N, and G. As in, “this market is going up, up, up.” To view a stock market chart, it’s an understandable statement, but it’s also dangerous. All the chart really tells us is that the market has gone up. Where it is going next is anyone’s guess. Beware the natural tendency to extrapolate financial market trends. (more…)
Note: This post is an excerpt from Gould Asset Management’s Economic and Market Review for the Third Quarter of 2017. The excerpt is posted here for the benefit of our blog subscribers.
US Economy Marches Forward at Measured Pace; Hurricanes’ Impact Felt
Q2 GDP rebounded after a relatively weak first quarter. Second quarter readings came in at a 3.1% annualized rate, driven by strong consumer spending. Although Hurricanes Harvey and Irma will impact third quarter growth, reconstruction activity and federal hurricane relief efforts should help boost the economy next quarter.
Showing its first signs of life in several months, core inflation ticked up 0.2% in August, which may soothe some concerns of a broad slowing. It will take more readings, however, to determine if the pickup can be sustained.
Consumer confidence fell in the wake of the Texas and Florida hurricanes, but remained relatively high at 119.8 in September. The labor market was a bright spot, with fewer saying jobs are hard to get.
The headline unemployment rate fell to 4.2% in September despite the first decline in nonfarm payrolls in seven years, a dip largely attributed to hurricane effects. Wage growth, which had been stagnant much of this year, spiked 0.5% last month, another sign of a tightening job market.
The housing sector had trouble building momentum going into year-end, and Harvey and Irma dampened the outlook further. Going into the fourth quarter, it seems unlikely housing will be a significant near-term contributor to economic growth.
In early September, Congress reached a deal to raise the debt ceiling and extend government funding for three months. Next on the agenda is a tax reform bill; passage is highly uncertain, and views on its likely economic impact vary widely. (more…)
Note: This post is an excerpt from Gould Asset Management’s Economic and Market Review for the Second Quarter of 2017. The excerpt is posted here for the benefit of our blog subscribers.
US Stocks Move Steadily Higher, Show Little Regard for Political Uncertainties
Despite increasing political turbulence, US stocks marched methodically higher in the second quarter, with the S&P 500 stock index rising 3.1% for the period. The strong gains, combined with robust first quarter returns, puts US stocks up 9.3% for the year. With the political storm at times seemingly growing by the day, the stock market’s orderly rise was a welcome and reassuring surprise to many investors.
The technology and healthcare sectors remained red hot and have now risen 14.3% and 16.0% respectively on the year. If you take just Facebook, Amazon, Netflix, and Google (now Alphabet)—known as the FANG stocks—and add Apple and Microsoft to the mix, the group has risen an average of 22% in 2017 and accounts for nearly one third of the S&P 500’s total return on the year. Gains in the healthcare sector have been equally impressive and seem to be driven by increasing skepticism among investors that significant healthcare reforms will be passed by Congress.
Large cap stocks continued to outperform mid and small cap stocks in the second quarter, as the Wilshire 4500 index rose 2.9%, compared to the S&P 500’s 3.1% gain. This continues a trend that began in the first quarter of the year and can be traced in part to the surge of some of the large technology firms mentioned above, which have a big impact on capitalization weighted market indices. A weak US dollar, which fell 2.3% in the second quarter, also boosted large-cap returns, as profits earned abroad translated into more US dollars for large multinational firms.
Market volatility readings hovered near all-time lows on the quarter, providing formal confirmation that markets were in fact as tranquil as they seemed. The VIX volatility index spent most of the quarter under 11, and even dipped below 10 on occasion—not too far off from its all-time closing low of 9.3.